Mr. Dye's Pies
Named Best Pie Shop in Wisconsin by USAToday.
What are grandmas gonna do now?
Hours
Contact
mrdyespies.net
Menu
Menu items & prices subject to change - visit our store to view current offerings
Pies
Good STuff
Hall Map
Location
First Floor, South Hall
Come find us in the South Hall! We’re right across from Dawg City
Grab a slice, half or whole pie today!
About Mr. Dye's Pies
Mr. Dye’s Pies started with a single mission: to bake pies that taste like home. Founded by Johnathan Dye, our bakery has blossomed into a beloved Milwaukee staple, nestled inside 3rd Street Market Hall. Every pie—sweet or savory—is crafted with passion, tradition, and a sprinkle of local pride.
Today, we take pride in offering both our celebrated sweet pies and a bold new twist: savory pasties, perfect for when you crave something hearty as much as something sweet.
One slice at a time
Mr. Johnathan Dye has been making some of the best pies on earth since 2011. What are grandmas gonna do now?
